Visit Killfile's column >>

KILLFILEHome Page

Epicurean Intelligentsia
Add To Watchlist
Articles Posted: 305; Links Seeded: 7617
Member Since: 2/2006Last Seen: 11/25/2009

An Asteroid Exploded Over Indonesia With the Force of Three Hiroshima-Size Nuclear Bombs This Month... No One Saw It Coming

advertisement

AN ASTEROID exploded over Indonesia with the force of three Hiroshima nuclear bombs - and no one on Earth knew it was coming.

The New Scientist website reports the dramatic explosion over South Sulawesi, Indonesia, on October 8 underscores how blind humanity is to the danger of giant space rocks.

What's this?
Who's leading the conversation?
This visualization below allows you to see the impact that each user has on the current conversation. The top row contains the group of users who have had the most impact, the 2nd row the group of users who have had the 2nd most impact (et cetera). Users with similar impact are grouped together, and the average score of the group is shown to the left of the group. The author of the article is also shown on the left, in their corresponding group. Each user's score is based on the number of comments the user has made plus the number of votes their comments have received. The scores are calculated relative one another, so while their absolute value is not particularly important, their relative difference does indicate a larger difference in impact on the conversation.
109
55
6.5
1.1
{"commentId":10331426,"authorDomain":"skylark246"}

Scary.

{"commentId":10331426,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"skylark246"}
  • 7 votes
Reply#1 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 10:34 AM EDT
{"commentId":10338141,"authorDomain":"cletuswilbury"}

Youtube video shows trail.

{"commentId":10338141,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"cletuswilbury"}
  • 3 votes
#1.1 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 2:41 PM EDT
{"commentId":10341357,"authorDomain":"donstahoe"}

Well it is a BIG ASS SKY. what do you expect? can't possibly watch it all with the spending going to other areas that is deemed to be more important...

{"commentId":10341357,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"donstahoe"}
  • 1 vote
#1.2 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 4:26 PM EDT
{"commentId":10345425,"authorDomain":"michelleUT"}

Well it is a BIG ASS SKY. what do you expect? can't possibly watch it all with the spending going to other areas that is deemed to be more important...

Oh good Christ...wah wah wah. Even WITH the cash, you can't watch the entire sky.

{"commentId":10345425,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"michelleUT"}
  • 1 vote
#1.3 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 7:20 PM EDT
{"commentId":10347470,"authorDomain":"CL1"}

I've pretty much always thought if it isn't a nuclear bomb, then it's going to be an asteroid. Can't win!

{"commentId":10347470,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"CL1"}
  • 3 votes
#1.4 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 9:43 PM EDT
{"commentId":10348759,"authorDomain":"donstahoe"}
I am AmericanDeleted
{"commentId":10352193,"authorDomain":"donstahoe"}

1.3

AT what point did I say we could watch the whole DAMN sky? Oh yeah I DIDN"T! Stop the ASSUMING. read the post for what it says nothing more or less

WAH WAH WAH childish

{"commentId":10352193,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"donstahoe"}
  • 1 vote
#1.6 - Thu Oct 29, 2009 9:26 AM EDT
{"commentId":10402874,"authorDomain":"luckydog"}

Interesting seed. Clipped to Odd News Group.

{"commentId":10402874,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"luckydog"}
  • 1 vote
#1.7 - Sat Oct 31, 2009 10:22 PM EDT
Reply
{"commentId":10332092,"authorDomain":"sevenwishes35"}
Schroedingers CatExpand Comment Comment collapsed by the community

Over Indonesia huh!...Frankly, too bad it didn't take out the large contingent of Radical Islamists there!

{"commentId":10332092,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"sevenwishes35"}
  • 7 votes
Reply#2 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 11:00 AM EDT
{"commentId":10332417,"authorDomain":"jaljones"}

You know just because you put the word "radical" before Islamists doesn't make it any less inflamatory, biggotted or less ignorant. What if everyone starts referring to Isralei's as Radical Zionist Jews, or Germans as radical christians? To wish mass death and destruction on any population is hateful and anti...well antihuman. Have a biggoted day...

{"commentId":10332417,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"jaljones"}
  • 15 votes
#2.1 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 11:11 AM EDT
{"commentId":10332628,"authorDomain":"killfile"}

Because when you drop giant rocks from space onto populated areas it only kills the people who are actively plotting acts of terrorism.

What kind of a monster would wish such widespread death and destruction upon so many innocents? Even if every man of military age in Indonesia wanted to destroy the United States (they don't) you'd be writing off the deaths of countless women and children.

Thinking like that is what crashed planes into the World Trade Center and Pentagon. Thinking like that is what we should be fighting against.

{"commentId":10332628,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"killfile"}
  • 20 votes
#2.2 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 11:18 AM EDT
{"commentId":10334649,"authorDomain":"butair"}

What is the population of Indonesia and the "contingent of Radical Islamists" there and where are they located? To wish widespread death and destruction... it can surely happen anywhere like Manhattan, Chicago, Miami... right? Wouldn't it have been absolutely fantastic for the rock to explode a few hrs later and take out London... they haven't helped us in our fight against terrorism like how we want them to? I wish the death on Europe for standing by and not helping us fight the menace of terrorism!

{"commentId":10334649,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"butair"}
  • 2 votes
#2.3 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 12:29 PM EDT
{"commentId":10335397,"authorDomain":"sevenwishes35"}

...YAWN!

{"commentId":10335397,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"sevenwishes35"}
  • 2 votes
#2.4 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 12:54 PM EDT
{"commentId":10336510,"authorDomain":"sevenwishes35"}

Yes I am aware that many of you think my comment monstrous, but just WHO is being a monster here? Me, who read the riot act to the guy who is painting my house for killing a mouse who is attempting entry into said house,OR the Radical zealous Islamists who daily strap explosives to themselves and MURDER innocent people of any religion on a DAILY basis??? I am an Atheist so killing people of any religious stripe by any other religion is par for the course and totally against my grain. I'm just getting sick and tired of Muslims not standing up against their own to stop this,and they call us in the west "infidels" and "Murderous" and un-clean. I am well aware of the significant contributions that Islam has brought forth into this world and that of Christians and Jews, but it is time for all of us to stop coddling the REAL crazies out there and remove them from this world before they can murder any more! And if it takes the form of an high velocity projectile from space then so be it. Look at recent history, that region has been a target of the earths own tectonic plate activity and meteorological events!...the Earth is trying to tell them and us something! I for one am listening!...How about the rest of you? If the Islamic community would have the courage that the western christians have and stand up to them then the past two decades would have been one that was more peaceful and less filled with murderous Islamist Extremists.

{"commentId":10336510,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"sevenwishes35"}
  • 3 votes
#2.5 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 1:36 PM EDT
{"commentId":10336909,"authorDomain":"killfile"}

I'm just getting sick and tired of Muslims not standing up against their own

Uh... they do. Lots of them. All the time. I'd say, on the aggregate, Muslims speak out more, in opposition to Islamist terrorist attacks, than say.... Americans spoke out against the torture of prisoners.

Now, there aren't a lot of Muslim cable TV channels that get a lot of play in the US, so you may not have seen that happen... but just because it wasn't on after The Simpsons doesn't mean it didn't happen.

How many Muslims do you know? Have you asked any about this?

{"commentId":10336909,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"killfile"}
  • 8 votes
#2.6 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 1:51 PM EDT
{"commentId":10337377,"authorDomain":"boats-001"}

So how can we tie this to Dick Cheney? I know he is responsible but I just don't know how. But if Bush was in office it would definitely been his fault that we did no detect it and prevent it.

So what if we had a 24 hour warning? What then. Just sit there and watch? Not much Else you could do. And besides if it killed a few hundred thousand, wouldn't that help the supposed global warming problem?

Barack should have known.

{"commentId":10337377,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"boats-001"}
    #2.7 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 2:10 PM EDT
    {"commentId":10337481,"authorDomain":"sevenwishes35"}

    Killfile, I'm aware of the fact that they are standing up against them but it is up to the Islamic media to make this more open and available. But by in large we Americans and christians arebearing the lions share of battling them while their own are taking the brunt of the deaths. There are very few Muslims here in Lancaster and yet living in this mostly white christian community their disdain for Americans is thick enough to cut with a scimitar. I avoid them not because I dislike them personally but because a discussion of the FACTS would only serve to enrage them and cause more problems. I dated a woman from Iran years ago and you could not ask for a sweeter person who was disowned and threatened with death from her family for associating with Americans and converting to christianity. After a heated discussion with her family I was able to temper their HATRED of Americans and her conversion. Her father said and I quote..." if more Americans and Christians were as pragmatic and FAIR minded as you, then we would not be in the situation that we find ourselves in" He himself does not condone the actions of his relatives but still holds a small amount of animosity towards the west and christians, I fear that many feel this way but will never fully admit to it.

    {"commentId":10337481,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"sevenwishes35"}
    • 1 vote
    #2.8 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 2:14 PM EDT
    {"commentId":10337817,"authorDomain":"killfile"}

    it is up to the Islamic media to make this more open and available

    Do you make a habit of watching Islamic media? It hardly seems reasonable to equate its comparative unpopularity with non-Muslims to a failure of the Muslim community to denounce terrorism.

    Muslims all over the world have spoken out against terrorism and against suicide bombings and the like. The fact that you haven't heard about it doesn't mean it didn't happen.

    {"commentId":10337817,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"killfile"}
    • 7 votes
    #2.9 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 2:28 PM EDT
    {"commentId":10349576,"authorDomain":"LeeMB"}

    we Americans and christians

    You can honesntly just stop responding already. You're biggoted self-centered/closed-minded attitude has been noted.

    {"commentId":10349576,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"LeeMB"}
      #2.10 - Thu Oct 29, 2009 1:15 AM EDT
      {"commentId":10349641,"authorDomain":"screamingeagle-bct"}

      First off, sorry to Killfile for this being soooo, off topic; but...

      Schroedingers Cat, you are an admitted atheist and yet you said:

      Look at recent history, that region has been a target of the earths own tectonic plate activity and meteorological events!...the Earth is trying to tell them and us something! I for one am listening!.

      I just think its very interesting that you deny a supreme intelligent being and yet you imply intelligence in the earth itself. Maybe you were just making a point and not actually suggesting that the earth "knows" how bad the extremists are and is willing them to be obliterated; and yet, from your user-name, I would think that perhaps you do see the universe itself as cognizant. What are your thoughts on this? I'm not poking fun or looking for an argument; it would just make such a horribly interesting dialogue.

      {"commentId":10349641,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"screamingeagle-bct"}
        #2.11 - Thu Oct 29, 2009 1:25 AM EDT
        Reply
        {"commentId":10332507,"authorDomain":"killfile"}

        Ok, so a high altitude explosion but still... imagine if that had been over Los Angeles. Imagine if it had been lower.

        It's difficult to visualize exactly how nasty this could be but there are some really simple google maps mashups that do a pretty good job of drawing unpleasant looking circles to give you an idea.

        {"commentId":10332507,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"killfile"}
        • 6 votes
        Reply#3 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 11:14 AM EDT
        {"commentId":10350074,"authorDomain":"jimsfurniture"}

        OK Lets stop this right here, lets no imagine it, 90 per cent of things we worry about never happen, thats never. If a big rock is coming then dont worry about it, let the Yankess use Arod to catch it and we are all safe, end of story. Now go back to your worrying about something else useless

        {"commentId":10350074,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"jimsfurniture"}
          #3.1 - Thu Oct 29, 2009 2:49 AM EDT
          {"commentId":10350442,"authorDomain":"antoniowillia20"}

          Killfile

          Now I'm not a worry-wort but 2 nights ago I had the scariest dream dealing with this very issue. I even wrote about it and posted it here on the vine. "What really matters. What would you do?" Just to get it off my chest. Believe me it's better that it explodes in space than to have an impact in a populated area. After that dream I'll happily read about explosions in space over having an extinction level event.

          {"commentId":10350442,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"antoniowillia20"}
            #3.2 - Thu Oct 29, 2009 4:59 AM EDT
            {"commentId":10350530,"authorDomain":"boonsorama"}

            "Now go back to your worrying about something else useless"

            Do you support the War on Terror? If so, I find your attitude ironic...

            {"commentId":10350530,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"boonsorama"}
            • 1 vote
            #3.3 - Thu Oct 29, 2009 5:47 AM EDT
            {"commentId":10352602,"authorDomain":"mndrmnn"}

            Thanks for the laugh, Boons!

            Nah, we shouldn't worry about asteroids any more than we should worry about Bin Laden hiding under our childrens' beds.

            All the same, sometimes bad things happen.

            Now if you'll excuse me, I have to go find my flashlight - it's dark under my childrens' beds.

            {"commentId":10352602,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"mndrmnn"}
              #3.4 - Thu Oct 29, 2009 9:52 AM EDT
              {"commentId":10361055,"authorDomain":"sevenwishes35"}

              Screamingeagle...Yes I know I said I'm an Atheist but you applied that portion of my comment to your posting trying to make the villain here. What I meant and YOU know it!,is how OTHER people would view it! Not ME! I was only trying to look at this from a believers point of view and being fair about it but you could not or would not recognize what I REALLY meant. And Killfile your reply 2.9 was way off point, I watch what most people watch in the news, I'm getting the SAME info YOU are getting so don't assume I am seeing what I want! I see what YOU see so don't high hand me and minimize what is really going on here. You should work for the Repubs. since you have shown yourself so adept at spinning to make me look uncaring and yourself so benign. You should know from my past postings how much I speak about peace and want it to be so, so your spinning of my comments are disingenuous and self serving.

              {"commentId":10361055,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"sevenwishes35"}
              • 1 vote
              #3.5 - Thu Oct 29, 2009 3:28 PM EDT
              Reply
              {"commentId":10332516,"authorDomain":"wingod"}

              Good catch Kill.

              It's just a matter of time before another Tuskunga sized event (1908). If that asteroid explosion had happened three hours later, goodby London. That event was about 10 megatons, 1,000 times bigger than Hiroshima.

              {"commentId":10332516,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"wingod"}
              • 15 votes
              Reply#4 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 11:14 AM EDT
              {"commentId":10332689,"authorDomain":"killfile"}

              To me it's the "three hours" part that really boggles my mind. We really have so little appreciation for how fast this top we live on in spinning and flying through space. Shift the time of impact just a little and "the middle of nowhere" becomes "Manhattan" or Rio, or Mexico City.

              When you step back and look at the numbers its terrifyingly random and capricious.

              {"commentId":10332689,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"killfile"}
              • 14 votes
              #4.1 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 11:20 AM EDT
              {"commentId":10332824,"authorDomain":"wingod"}

              Kill

              Yeppers! Here is a link to a foundation that wants to do something about this.

              http://www.b612foundation.org/

              A good friend of mine is Brian Marsden, who just retired from the Minor Planet Center. After the asteroid scares of about 15 years ago, we started calling him "Dr. Death". He got a kick out of it.

              {"commentId":10332824,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"wingod"}
              • 10 votes
              #4.2 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 11:25 AM EDT
              {"commentId":10337106,"authorDomain":"cletuswilbury"}

              Yes, another great catch, Kill.

              {"commentId":10337106,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"cletuswilbury"}
              • 2 votes
              #4.3 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 1:59 PM EDT
              {"commentId":10341881,"authorDomain":"barbieriam"}

              Good seed, if this story doesn't scare the livin $#&! out of you, I don't know what will.

              {"commentId":10341881,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"barbieriam"}
              • 5 votes
              #4.4 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 4:42 PM EDT
              {"commentId":10348464,"authorDomain":"wingod"}

              Here is a news video from Indonesia on the subject.

              http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yeQBzTkJNhs&feature=player_embedded#

              {"commentId":10348464,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"wingod"}
              • 3 votes
              #4.5 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 11:07 PM EDT
              {"commentId":10348689,"authorDomain":"lstcaress"}

              a giant meteor would be pretty quick and painless (right?).. on the other hand.. THIS does scare the living crap outta me! imagine going to sleep in your nice comfy bed and then waking with a damn car on top of you!

              killfile, good seed!

              {"commentId":10348689,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"lstcaress"}
              • 1 vote
              #4.6 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 11:28 PM EDT
              Reply
              {"commentId":10333666,"authorDomain":"kshark"}

              on October 8 underscores how blind humanity is to the danger of giant space rocks.

              And what are we supposed to do about them then? Do we have missile defense systems to blow the rocks away? A rock is coming, what exactly are humans supposed to do?

              {"commentId":10333666,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"kshark"}
              • 1 vote
              Reply#5 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 11:55 AM EDT
              {"commentId":10334963,"authorDomain":"killfile"}

              Well, the earlier we know something the more we can do. Distances in astronomy are... well... astronomical. Even if one of these city-sized rocks is hurtling at us at a dozen times the speed of sound, we could theoretically spot it a few years out (if we took the time and energy to look).

              Well... a few years out means you don't have to hit it all that hard... just push on it slightly for a long time. Think of driving an asteroid as being like driving a car. If you see that you're headed towards a tree that's a mile down the road you barely have to nudge the steering wheel to avoid it. If you happen to notice the tree when it's 10 feet away and your headed towards it at 70mph, however, there's not a lot you can do.

              The same thing is true of space rocks. Divert something from a collision course early enough and you scarcely have to nudge it. Wait until it's right on top of you, however, and you're pretty well screwed.

              {"commentId":10334963,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"killfile"}
              • 11 votes
              #5.1 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 12:40 PM EDT
              {"commentId":10335557,"authorDomain":"kshark"}

              Um yeah but comparing something that is in the solar system, and not on earth such as trees and cars doesn't really work all that well.

              You are basically trying to say let's move Earth out of the asteroid path. If you can do that, heck go for it.

              We're constantly under threat and scientists have predicted so many different years from 2014 all the way up to 2880.

              We're supposedly going to have a collision March 14, 2014 by 2003 QQ47, which was discovered in August 24, 2003. 2002 NT7 was supposed to hit in 2019, but that has been cleared.

              {"commentId":10335557,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"kshark"}
              • 1 vote
              #5.2 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 1:00 PM EDT
              {"commentId":10335652,"authorDomain":"mojo31979"}

              Actually, we don’t have to push it sideways enough to avoid Earth’s orbit. All we really have to do is speed up or slow down one of the two objects- Earth or the asteroid. Since we obviously do not want to alter Earth’s orbit around the sun, and because Earth will be orders of magnitude larger, we’d chose to alter the asteroid’s speed. If we sped up or slowed down the asteroid, its trajectory may still intersect Earth’s orbit. However, it will do so when the Earth is at a different location in its orbit, and thus avoid collision. I suppose either method would work though! Of course then we'd have to figure out a way to attach literally thousands of rockets to a planetary body, moving millions of miles per hour, and take into consideration of shifts in gravity, the speed of both objects and hope nothing goes wrong along the way..which is improbable. As Kshark pointed out, the trjectory of the planetary body would constantly be changing so predicting it's [ath would be "iffy" But I'm sure we'd try!

              {"commentId":10335652,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"mojo31979"}
              • 2 votes
              #5.3 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 1:04 PM EDT
              {"commentId":10336144,"authorDomain":"reddirthippy"}

              spot it a few years out (if we took the time and energy to look).

              And money --

              "A survey that finds all of the 20-metre objects will cost probably multiple billions of dollars."

              "If you want to find the smallest objects you have to build more, larger telescopes.

              {"commentId":10336144,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"reddirthippy"}
              • 2 votes
              #5.4 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 1:22 PM EDT
              {"commentId":10336621,"authorDomain":"jedipunk"}

              I can't even imagine how difficult it is to spot an asteroid in the solar system.

              It would be like trying find a spare key that might exist in a house as big the pacific ocean.

              Hell, I can't find my keys have the time in my house as it is...even when they are in front of my face.

              {"commentId":10336621,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"jedipunk"}
              • 3 votes
              #5.5 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 1:40 PM EDT
              {"commentId":10336856,"authorDomain":"wingod"}

              You are basically trying to say let's move Earth out of the asteroid path. If you can do that, heck go for it.

              No, we are not.

              I can't even imagine how difficult it is to spot an asteroid in the solar system.

              We do it all the time. Google LINEAR telescope, the "Minor Planet Center" to get more information.

              {"commentId":10336856,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"wingod"}
              • 2 votes
              #5.6 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 1:49 PM EDT
              {"commentId":10337169,"authorDomain":"jedipunk"}

              I can't even imagine how difficult it is to spot an asteroid in the solar system.

              We do it all the time. Google LINEAR telescope, the "Minor Planet Center" to get more information.

              Oh, I know we find asteroid all the time. I find my kids toys laying on the floor that they never seem to see.

              However, I am saying in the vastness of space, do we know what we are not finding?

              {"commentId":10337169,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"jedipunk"}
              • 2 votes
              #5.7 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 2:03 PM EDT
              {"commentId":10337301,"authorDomain":"killfile"}

              We can't search the whole universe but it takes a long long time for stuff to fall in from even the Asteroid Belt. It's within our capabilities to at least look for the really huge rocks w/in the solar system.

              I don't mean "20 meters" here. I'm talking about the sort of rocks that generate extinction level events.

              {"commentId":10337301,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"killfile"}
              • 2 votes
              #5.8 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 2:07 PM EDT
              {"commentId":10344051,"authorDomain":"kshark"}

              Killfile--

              Well if you have the money to roll out as clearly no one else does, and since we have a crap load more problems on earth, so I appoint you to fund and pay for and build whatever is possible to find and blast away asteroids.

              ----------------------------------------------------------

              mojo31979--

              LOL We would have a LOT more problems than just an asteroid.

              --------------------------------------------------------------------

              Ah well might as well start talking about all of this now and put everyone in true panic mode and paranoia.

              {"commentId":10344051,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"kshark"}
              • 1 vote
              #5.9 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 6:04 PM EDT
              {"commentId":10346168,"authorDomain":"swcity"}
              swcityDeleted
              {"commentId":10349162,"authorDomain":"bobomadder"}

              "Don't wanna close my eyyyeess...Don't wanna fall asleeepp!"

              All we need are Ben Affleck and Bruce Willis in a rocket and some dynamite.

              {"commentId":10349162,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"bobomadder"}
              • 2 votes
              #5.11 - Thu Oct 29, 2009 12:21 AM EDT
              Reply
              {"commentId":10336406,"authorDomain":"charles4000"}

              i think a missile command style asteroid shooting system would be great, and then let it rip on the intertubes so the willfully unemployed gamers can utilize their skill set and save the planet... shave the planet, yesh?
              or a diamondillium shield, or was it diamondonium...?

              {"commentId":10336406,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"charles4000"}
              • 2 votes
              Reply#6 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 1:32 PM EDT
              {"commentId":10337234,"authorDomain":"killfile"}

              or a diamondillium shield, or was it diamondonium...?

              Unobtainium

              {"commentId":10337234,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"killfile"}
              • 5 votes
              #6.1 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 2:05 PM EDT
              {"commentId":10341658,"authorDomain":"douglasq"}

              Apparently, the element upsidasium falls upward away from Earth whenever it is mined. I say we mine all we can and make warheads we can shoot at these meteorites. It will also be a boon the the economy of Frostbite Falls.

              {"commentId":10341658,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"douglasq"}
              • 2 votes
              #6.2 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 4:35 PM EDT
              {"commentId":10342226,"authorDomain":"charles4000"}

              sorry, multiple futurama references with a bit o' final fantasy x thrown in to boot... ; )

              {"commentId":10342226,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"charles4000"}
              • 1 vote
              #6.3 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 4:53 PM EDT
              Reply
              {"commentId":10338467,"authorDomain":"cyril1917"}

              A 45 to 50 kiloton explosion. People won't really pay attention unless we have another Tunguska-type event within 100 miles of a major city. How many megatons was that again?

              {"commentId":10338467,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"cyril1917"}
              • 1 vote
              Reply#7 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 2:53 PM EDT
              {"commentId":10338692,"authorDomain":"theskeptic-1418965"}

              So realistically, how BIG, how heavy was this "asteroid?"

              Exploding with a claimed 50 Kilotons comparable energy, that would make it 2.0 to 2.5 times the explosive power of the Hiroshima bomb.

              That nothing on the ground was damaged because the burst was 20 kilometers up is good, of course. But nevertheless surprising, that there was no damage below. Considering what the Tunguska explosion wreaked nearly a century earlier.

              So what or whom are we expected to blame for the asteroid not being spotted? What should we have done to avert it, one might ask? I would guess exploding a nuke against it, a few hundred miles out in space being a "no-no.

              {"commentId":10338692,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"theskeptic-1418965"}
                Reply#8 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 3:01 PM EDT
                {"commentId":10339751,"authorDomain":"cletuswilbury"}

                http://neat.jpl.nasa.gov/

                "Potentially Hazardous asteroids (PHAs) are larger than ~0.2 km (0.1 mile) and approach close enough to present a potential hazard but not a current hazard. "

                So that was much smaller than they consider hazardous, by my reading.

                http://neo.jpl.nasa.gov/programs/

                "In 1998 NASA commenced its part of the "Spaceguard" effort, with the goal of discovering and tracking over 90% of the near-Earth objects larger than one kilometer by the end of 2008."

                {"commentId":10339751,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"cletuswilbury"}
                  #8.1 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 3:38 PM EDT
                  {"commentId":10340614,"authorDomain":"cletuswilbury"}

                  Asteroid False Alarm Shows Limits of Alert Systems- March 8, 2004

                  The scare was the latest in a series of false alarms that highlights the apparent lack of procedure for dealing with a possible asteroid threat. Several astronomers complained they did not know whom to call in an emergency.

                  Last Tuesday, Lindley Johnson, a program scientist at NASA's Near-Earth Object Observation Program in Washington, D.C., sent a memo to a select group of asteroid experts. Should a potential impactor be detected, Johnson wrote, "You call me."

                  Very well. But what happens next? There is no government agency assigned to "protect the Earth." In theory, if Johnson's office is warned of an asteroid threat, the office would pass it along the chain of command to the NASA administrator, who would contact the President.

                  Asteroid "Near" Miss: False Alarm or Wake Up Call?

                  ...
                  Let me paraphrase a leading astronomical group's position paper on the potential threat of an asteroid impact: What greater feat could there be than to perhaps someday alter the course of an asteroid to prevent an impending disaster? And what greater tragedy, given our knowledge and abilities, than to be caught unprepared?

                  {"commentId":10340614,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"cletuswilbury"}
                    #8.2 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 4:04 PM EDT
                    {"commentId":10342632,"authorDomain":"wingod"}

                    So that was much smaller than they consider hazardous, by my reading.

                    Just remember that the big hole in Arizona (meteor crater), was caused by an object 28-32 meters in diameter.

                    The PHA designation is for one that will wipe out civilization. One the size that hit arizona would make for a very bad day in any city of the world.

                    Google the "Torino Scale" for asteroid impactors.

                    http://neo.jpl.nasa.gov/torino_scale.html

                    {"commentId":10342632,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"wingod"}
                    • 3 votes
                    #8.3 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 5:07 PM EDT
                    {"commentId":10343563,"authorDomain":"cletuswilbury"}

                    Thanks space_guy

                    This says 50 meters, but either way that's still much smaller than 0.1 mile, so your point remains.

                    http://www.americansouthwest.net/arizona/meteor_crater/index.html
                    Current theories place the size of the meteor as 150 feet in diameter, and its weight at 300,000 tons.

                    {"commentId":10343563,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"cletuswilbury"}
                      #8.4 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 5:43 PM EDT
                      {"commentId":10343691,"authorDomain":"wingod"}

                      Cletus

                      The size keeps changing all the time. I am going on what the folks that model the impacts tell me. Google "Jay Melosh, Meteor Crater, or Elizabetta Pizzario" as they did a study on the impact and have more recent data.

                      {"commentId":10343691,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"wingod"}
                      • 2 votes
                      #8.5 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 5:48 PM EDT
                      {"commentId":10343849,"authorDomain":"cletuswilbury"}

                      It doesn't matter in this discussion, it's down in the noise.

                      Excellent example.

                      {"commentId":10343849,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"cletuswilbury"}
                        #8.6 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 5:54 PM EDT
                        Reply
                        {"commentId":10339204,"authorDomain":"regina-upright"}

                        I watch the evening news everynight and I've never even heard of this story. Weird.

                        {"commentId":10339204,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"regina-upright"}
                          Reply#9 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 3:19 PM EDT
                          {"commentId":10347507,"authorDomain":"alkhidr"}

                          That's because it isn't a human interest story. I imagine there are other reasons as well--such as the fact that it was Indonesia and not New York City. And don't forget that the mainstream media stay away from any story that can't be done "in depth" in about thirty seconds. Just witness all the confusion above over what could be done to divert an asteroid. What! You mean we don't have to wait until the asteroid has a magnificent view of the Earth before we send Bruce Willis and company there to blow the beejeezuz out of it?! Probably when an impending asteroid is newsworthy, we'll be hearing about it from the bottom of five-mile crater rapidly filling up with a tsunami.

                          {"commentId":10347507,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"alkhidr"}
                            #9.1 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 9:46 PM EDT
                            {"commentId":10359010,"authorDomain":"regina-upright"}

                            Well said! Too funny.

                            {"commentId":10359010,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"regina-upright"}
                              #9.2 - Thu Oct 29, 2009 2:13 PM EDT
                              Reply
                              {"commentId":10340627,"authorDomain":"mightyblogger"}

                              Is this a real, factual, verified story?

                              As it turns out, yes it is:

                              NASA: Asteroid Impactor Reported over Indonesia
                              October 23, 2009

                              This is some scary stuff.

                              {"commentId":10340627,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"mightyblogger"}
                                Reply#10 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 4:04 PM EDT
                                {"commentId":10340708,"authorDomain":"mightyblogger"}

                                On October 8, 2009 about 03:00 Greenwich time, an atmospheric fireball blast was observed and recorded over an island region of Indonesia. The blast is thought to be due to the atmospheric entry of a small asteroid about 10 meters in diameter that, due to atmospheric pressure, detonated in the atmosphere with an energy of about 50 kilotons (the equivalent of 100,000 pounds of TNT explosives).

                                The blast was recorded visually and reported upon by local media representatives. See the YouTube video at:

                                http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yeQBzTkJNhs&videos=jkRJgbXY-90

                                {"commentId":10340708,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"mightyblogger"}
                                • 1 vote
                                #10.1 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 4:07 PM EDT
                                Reply
                                {"commentId":10341954,"authorDomain":"snakeman111"}

                                Indeed scary, but even if they knew a asteroid was going to hit(especialy a very large asteroid that could seriously damage the planet) do you think they would inform the public or just deal with the problem afterwards rather then deal with public hysteria also?

                                {"commentId":10341954,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"snakeman111"}
                                  Reply#11 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 4:45 PM EDT
                                  {"commentId":10342098,"authorDomain":"demoscout"}

                                  Jim: If a really big one were to hit us I'm afraied there would be no way to deal with it afterwards, unless you would classify starting civilization over from scratch as dealing with it. UFOs stand by we may need you.

                                  {"commentId":10342098,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"demoscout"}
                                    #11.1 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 4:49 PM EDT
                                    {"commentId":10359970,"authorDomain":"snakeman111"}

                                    Would you want to know if It was going to hit? I know I would, Id rather spend my last days with my friends and family then shopping or working.

                                    {"commentId":10359970,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"snakeman111"}
                                      #11.2 - Thu Oct 29, 2009 2:46 PM EDT
                                      Reply
                                      {"commentId":10341984,"authorDomain":"demoscout"}

                                      It may be terrifying but there is nothing we can do about these little rock bombs. And the Earth has been absorbing them for billions of years.

                                      Maybe God threw a rock at us to wake us up and get us to act a little more decent toward each other. Trouble with God is he (she) never just sends a note.

                                      {"commentId":10341984,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"demoscout"}
                                      • 1 vote
                                      Reply#12 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 4:46 PM EDT
                                      {"commentId":10342664,"authorDomain":"wingod"}

                                      It may be terrifying but there is nothing we can do about these little rock bombs. And the Earth has been absorbing them for billions of years.

                                      Of course there is something that we can do. We have the technology to deflect all but the very largest impactors today, we just are not spending the money to get ready.

                                      {"commentId":10342664,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"wingod"}
                                      • 2 votes
                                      #12.1 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 5:08 PM EDT
                                      {"commentId":10343480,"authorDomain":"regina-upright"}

                                      Maybe everbody accidentaly deleted God's (him or her) e-mail because everbody thought it was spam or some scam. Who knows?

                                      {"commentId":10343480,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"regina-upright"}
                                      • 1 vote
                                      #12.2 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 5:40 PM EDT
                                      {"commentId":10352800,"authorDomain":"mndrmnn"}

                                      Ah, there was a note tied to the rock God threw at us.

                                      We would have been able to read it before it disintegrated if only we had bothered to develop a telescope that would have seen it.

                                      Our bad.

                                      {"commentId":10352800,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"mndrmnn"}
                                        #12.3 - Thu Oct 29, 2009 10:02 AM EDT
                                        Reply
                                        {"commentId":10342399,"authorDomain":"marxfan123"}

                                        Isn't 3 years to early, 2012 and all that stuff definitely a brown trouser day.

                                        {"commentId":10342399,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"marxfan123"}
                                          Reply#13 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 4:59 PM EDT
                                          {"commentId":10345354,"authorDomain":"dryver008"}

                                          A Killfile story that doesn't invoke race baiting or demonizing Republicans with agenda driven links? This is a real treat.

                                          {"commentId":10345354,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"dryver008"}
                                          • 1 vote
                                          Reply#14 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 7:16 PM EDT
                                          {"commentId":10346855,"authorDomain":"harrellb1"}

                                          Asteroid my ass................

                                          {"commentId":10346855,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"harrellb1"}
                                            Reply#15 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 8:58 PM EDT
                                            {"commentId":10347014,"authorDomain":"perezluis2000"}

                                            run , run and fill the Churches , ask for forgiveness for being

                                            so shelfisassdognestylowmotherfucional.

                                            kiss your dog because you value more the life of an animal than a human life

                                            get IN your knees and garb the ground and ask for forgiveness for so many destruction in the name of progress and greatness

                                            {"commentId":10347014,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"perezluis2000"}
                                              Reply#16 - Wed Oct 28, 2009 9:09 PM EDT
                                              {"commentId":10350366,"authorDomain":"stinkweepete"}

                                              You know, Atari has been preaching the dangers of these space projectiles since 1979, and no one has heeded the warnings.

                                              It's our own damn fault if we get blasted.

                                              {"commentId":10350366,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"stinkweepete"}
                                              • 3 votes
                                              Reply#17 - Thu Oct 29, 2009 4:23 AM EDT
                                              {"commentId":10351070,"authorDomain":"theskeptic-1418965"}

                                              Could we blame WTC, GWB or should we blame BHO?

                                              Seriously, I'd expect smallish objects like this would be hard to spot photographically. Radar might or might not pick them up far enough out to make deflection feasible. A larger asteroid, the kind that would devastate a continent, would naturally be brighter and more likely to be discovered in time to make a deflection attempt feasible.

                                              But these smaller bolides rarely survive to reach ground. I'd suspect most will break up high enough to leave only small fragments reaching the ground. Also, and this IS a big plus for us. . . the majority of our planet is covered with water (good old H2O). Sort of stacking the odds in our favor. . . respective to a no-damage impact.

                                              The story is interesting. . . but hardly worth getting alarmed over. Given there was, from anything I've heard or read, NO DAMAGE, WHATSOEVER at ground level. Like no impact damage. No massive fires started. Certainly no radiation like you'd have gotten from a nuclear blast that high up. So really, other than evoking unnecessary alarm in gullible people, what's the point of the tag line: "nobody saw it coming" if not to get people to dump on NASA and the government?

                                              {"commentId":10351070,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"theskeptic-1418965"}
                                                Reply#18 - Thu Oct 29, 2009 7:54 AM EDT
                                                {"commentId":10351891,"authorDomain":"Pvt-Public"}

                                                Could this have been a missile test from N.Korea? Where are the conspiracy theorists when you really need them?

                                                {"commentId":10351891,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"Pvt-Public"}
                                                • 1 vote
                                                Reply#19 - Thu Oct 29, 2009 9:07 AM EDT
                                                {"commentId":10368540,"authorDomain":"o-kelso"}

                                                Not scary at all. If and when it happens, I could only hope that it is quick and total.

                                                {"commentId":10368540,"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385","authorDomain":"o-kelso"}
                                                  Reply#20 - Thu Oct 29, 2009 11:22 PM EDT
                                                  {"canLink":false,"threadId":"711412","isPrivate":false}
                                                  Leave a Comment:
                                                  You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
                                                  As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.
                                                  {"threadId":"711412","contentId":"3434385"}
                                                  Start TrackingStart Tracking
                                                  Stop TrackingStop Tracking